|
|
'Shopping while black': Marketplace finds some shoppers targeted by retailers
because of race
Monitoring shoppers based on the colour of their skin violates human rights
codes, but it does happen
It's called "shopping while black." When the colour of your skin can get you
increased attention from a store's security guards. And it seems to happen every
day.
Consumer racial profiling is a violation of provincial human rights codes, but
some security guards admit it happens, a CBC Marketplace investigation
reveals.
When an employee asked Mary McCarthy to open her backpack in a Shoppers Drug
Mart in Toronto in 2011, it took her a moment to understand why. And then
she knew.
I realized I was being accused of being a thief, I was being accused of
stealing," says McCarthy, who is from Fredericton. I was a 55-year-old,
middle-aged black woman and I didn't deserve that treatment."
In a special months-long investigation, Marketplace looked at how race and
culture influence how companies treat shoppers, apartment-hunters and
job-seekers across Canada.
Some shoppers followed
A 2013 report for Nova Scotia's Consumer Racial Profiling Project found major
differences in how people are treated based on the colour of their skin.
Almost three-quarters of aboriginal respondents reported being followed by store
staff, while 62.7 per cent of black Canadians reported being followed while
shopping. Just 23.6 per cent of white respondents reported that they had
experienced being followed.
Watch a special, one-hour Marketplace report, Are we racist?, this Friday on
CBC Television at 8 p.m. (8:30 p.m. NT) or online.
Visit CBCNews.ca at 11:30 a.m. on Friday for an online discussion on when to
intervene when you see discrimination.
CBC Marketplace tested consumer-based racial profiling in major chains across
Canada, documenting how three male shoppers of different racial backgrounds -
one white, one black and one aboriginal - were treated in 15 stores across five
cities.
All three wore similar clothing, carried almost identical bags and followed
specific instructions: they all acted in the same manner and visited the same
aisles.
While most locations treated the three men the same, at other locations, they
got very different levels of attention.
Mark Simms, a Jamaican-Canadian, was offered help three times and then followed
around the store while shopping at a Best Buy location in Fredericton.
The white shopper was offered help once and then left to browse.
A security expert who works for several large retailers -- and who asked
to remain anonymous for fear of losing his job -- watched the hidden camera
footage. He told Marketplace this technique is frequently used to monitor
shoppers identified as suspicious in order to let them know they're being
watched.
In a Shoppers Drug Mart in Regina, Rory McCusker, who is white, noticed
he was watched by an employee.
McCusker says he was surprised by the attention. "It was a little weird because
I've never been followed in a store before."
But when aboriginal shopper Leeland Delorme entered the same store, he
was followed by multiple staff members and was tracked as he moved from
aisle to aisle.
Delorme says this type of experience has happened to him before. "This is
exactly what I expect from this city," he says. "I'm sorry to say I am not
shocked at all. But it still pisses me off."
Shoppers Drug Mart says it takes these allegations "very seriously."
We are currently looking into the footage of the alleged incident that took
place in the Regina store location and will take appropriate action, if
necessary," a spokesperson wrote to Marketplace in an email.
Best Buy says it doesn't tolerate discrimination. "These allegations go against
everything we expect from our employees and everything we stand for as a
company," the company wrote in an email.
'It does happen'
Even though it's against the law, racial profiling by security guards does
happen, one current security consultant told Marketplace.
"We'd have a different code name for certain different people, of different
ethnic backgrounds," he says. "When certain ethnic backgrounds or a black
minority would come in, that code name would be called out on the radio."
When Tomee Sojourner was a security guard, she remembers being told by a site
supervisor to follow a group of black youths.
"What caught me off-guard was I was a black youth in my 20s. He was telling me
to basically follow myself," she says.
"Most retailers won't acknowledge it, so part of getting them to even hear these
recommendations is to talk about it in a language that they understand," she
says.
Sojourner, who is now a Master of Law candidate at York University's Osgoode Law
School, last week presented a report on consumer racial profiling to the Ontario
Human Rights Commission. The organization is looking to develop a new policy on
the subject.
cbc.ca
Retailer's Alert:
Robberies at banks, retail on rise in Toronto
Retail Robberies Up 31% First Two Months of '16
Bank robberies and store hold-ups are on the rise so far this year in Toronto.
"Both bank robberies and retail robberies are up. We've been very busy in the
first couple of months of the year. We saw five bank heists in a single day
recently and retail robberies occur pretty much daily," says Toronto Police
Staff-Insp. Mike Earl in charge of the Holdup Squad.
"We're monitoring the situation and collecting data, so it's too soon to
speculate on why we're seeing this spike. But it's almost like the people
committing these robberies lack the fear of apprehension."
"Our arrests are actually up in each of the last four years - the numbers are
constantly rising. We've also made some significant arrests in the last two
months as we work hard to try and curb these robberies."
RETAIL/BUSINESS ROBBERIES
2015: 52 by end of February
2016: 68 in first two months of year (with five days left in February)
= 31% increase
torontosun.com
Shoppers Drug Mart says pharmacies are 'safest option' for medical marijuana
Canada's largest drugstore chain made the statement Wednesday after the Globe
and Mail, citing unnamed sources, reported that Shoppers is looking at the
possibility of selling medical marijuana. The Globe reported that Shoppers,
which is owned by Loblaw , has held several meetings with medical marijuana
producers and suppliers over the past year.
Editor's Note: Some ask what's the difference between Canada and the U.S. Well
folks here it is. You'd never see CVS or Walgreens making this statement.
Regardless of your position on the subject this approach and bold comment is at
the root of the difference between the U.S. and Canada. More liberal, open, and
relaxed maybe the U.S. needs to listen. canada.com
Victoria's Secret stops its expansion in Canada
due to weak dollar
Nordstrom begins hiring for its two Toronto stores
- LP Jobs?
Sears Home Canada to close 8 stores assigning
leases to Leon's
Lowe's Canada to open 12 new stores in '16
Simons looks to grow a Canadian retail empire
Kit and Ace lays off 35 corporate employees
Halifax mall shooting plot case set for May 2017 trial
The pair accused of plotting mass murder at the Halifax Shopping Centre are now
scheduled to go to trial in the spring of 2017. Lindsay Souvannarath and Randall
Shepherd made a brief appearance in Nova Scotia Supreme Court this morning. The
pair are charged with conspiracy to commit arson, conspiracy to commit murder,
uttering threats and other charges. They were arrested Feb. 13, 2015, just hours
before they were to allegedly carry out an attack on a mall full of shoppers.
They have been in custody ever since.
cbc.ca
Toronto, CN: Photo released of suspect wanted in GTA credit card scam
Toronto police are asking for the public's help in identifying a suspect wanted
in connection with a fraud investigation. On Sept. 15 and Sept. 18, a man
allegedly contacted a business in the Port Union Road and Highway 401 area and
ordered items over the phone. Police said the man provided the business with
credit card information and picked up the purchased items that same day. It was
later discovered that the credit card used was fraudulent. Officials said
further investigation revealed the man has defrauded multiple people across the GTA using the same method.
citynews.ca
Brandon, MB: Bloody trail of stolen guns
A pair of semi-automatic handguns stolen from a Brandon store nearly four years
ago have turned up under disturbing circumstances in other communities. One was
found lying next to a man in Thompson who had killed himself, while another was
found in the possession of a gang member during an investigation into a shooting
in Edmonton. Over a dozen weapons were stolen during a Burglary of Jo-Brook
Firearms in Brandon in 2012. Justice John Menzies said it's likely 11 to 12
handguns stolen from the store are in the hands of crooks.
winnipegfreepress.com
Windsor: Caught on cam: Robbery Suspect Gets Locked In
Windsor police are asking for the public's help identifying a suspect in a
convenience store robbery on Albert Road. Police released video of the alleged
robber, who got away after being locked inside the store by the employee. The
armed robber approached the clerk and demanded cash. While the suspect was
focused on the register the clerk ran out of the store and locked the door from
the outside. The complainant ran to a neighbor and called the police. The clerk
returned when officers arrived and found that the lock on the door was broke off
and the suspect was gone.
ctvnews.ca
Peoples Jewellers in the
Cornwall Square, Cornwall, ON was the victim of a Grab & Run theft on 2/24 at
8:20pm, male suspect fled with a Men's Movado watch valued at $1,150
|
| |
|
|